questions

Why are platinum trophies the only type that show the full count (including repeatables) on a player's profile?

Good question

Because they are the only ones that matter

I was going to post that response also Draoi....

Hm, that does seem to be a bug.

I could of swore you said something contradictory to this earlier. :P

maybe you're thinking of how all trophies used to show in the hof, but that was changed to only show plats. maybe.

I do remember Ender saying that monthly plats are the only trophies he intended to count multiple times towards total trophy count.

Yeah, I thought so also.

Multiple trophies that show you obtained level 10 being counted toward your total trophy count seems silly to me. I think it's working like it should.

one man's multiple bronze is another man's plat.

Oh yeah, now that other people are mentioning it, I do remember saying that the only repeatable trophies that can counts multiple times towards your total count are platinums, so I guess it's not a bug.

The trophy system has a few weird corner cases like this (off the top of my head, there's this and the fact that All Star is non-repeatable for count but repeatable for points) that make it confusing. The fact that I made the thing and I can't keep it straight says something. :) One day I'll make it more intelligent/understandable.