suggestions

i think itd be cool to have like a clan bank where one can donate kudos to be safe and can be transfered to other bots in the clan. it would be seperate of the treasury. i dunno just an idea...

Suggested a billion times.

No.

just thought itd be cool.

click

50 plus results, check them all and they will be "Suggested before, no bank"

Or about how some guy works in a bank apparently.

No bank, no bank, NO BANK, no offence but this comes up all the time and is annoying.

Sticky please.

Definitely no, also +1 to the sticky idea. Maybe we can put some commonly suggested ideas that get rejected every time?

Perhaps explaining why this is a bad idea would be better than just slapping him around with "It's already been suggested and it sucks, go die!"

It's a bad idea because higher levels bots could give to the "clan bank" and lower level bots could take from the "clan bank" and essentially be stronger due to this. Consider having the ability to obtain 5 mil kudos at lvl 20.

Thanks for the explanation nos.

You're welcome and I hope you understand the reasoning as well.

Yea I understand. But what if there was a max amount that one could take out. And that amount increases by level. Like say at lvl 20 one can only take out a maximum of 20k kudos and limit it to one withdraw per day.

It's increase the amount of players looking to get into clans and help out new players who are not conscious of how much kudos they'll need to get decent armour.

I dunno I just think we can build on it. I've played games with clans and they've all had banks that are used to help out newbies. Not sure if it'd work on this game but im just throwin out ideas. Lol

And hopefully I don't get flames for speaking mind again haha

Sorry for typos. On my iPhone and I hate the autocorrect lol

That actually has more potential, but the idea behind a bank still gives anyone joining a clan the advantage over others who don't which in my opinion shouldn't be the case. Everyone should remain in the same playing field, regardless of their choices to play alone or as a team.

This of course only goes with similar types, obviously in a game where "perks" can be purchased with real money those willing to pay will usually always have the advantage, that's the way games like that)this) goes.

I say a clan bank as suggested would actually even out some of the differences in this game. As you just said, those who want to pay already have quite an advantage (-> Trophies) even at lvl 20 so for a low lvl (non paying) to join a clan and then being able to get some help is just a plus.

You could e.g. make the withdraw-able amount of star buyers to be the half of non-paying players, additional to the lvl boundaries.

As Ender mentioned few times already, star users won't gonna get more advantages against regular players in the near future. So don't waste time with these ridiculous ideas (sorry but they are ridiculous...)

Stop trying to make things easier.

ok then remove the insurance again?

star users won't gonna get more advantages against regular players in the near future.

how is a bank an advantage for star users?

just leave things the way they are

how is a bank an advantage for star users?

Quoting you:

You could e.g. make the withdraw-able amount of star buyers to be the half of non-paying players, additional to the lvl boundaries.

To me that reads that he is suggesting star owners only be able to withdraw half as much as non star owners

Yeah neps, I think you misread.

Oh sorry, my bad, I did.

if ender didnt want things to change then he wouldnt have this suggestion thread. games evolve with the players. in my opinion i think a bank with certain restrictions would benefit everyone. we could even coincide it with energy and clan raids...for instance, say one clan attacks another clan and also steals a small percentage of kudos from the bank along with energy...there are many ways the bank can help this game. i can go on with this example but whats the point if everyone is automatically dissing it...

try and think outside the box. this idea can go many different directions. dont throw it out because its been mentioned before and denied. put some thought into it. i think itd keep alot of new players around if you ask me. considering how much itd help them.

As it stands atm I can not see that a clan bank is required & wiggin himself has said no & I believe explained his reasons as to why not.

However I think we need to see where wiggin goes with clans, PvP & PvE before any further useful discussion can be made on this subject.

So in the future who knows ...

its not required. i just think itd be pretty useful. but yes i agree with you. we also need to see where he goes with the clan system. cause this idea wouldnt work properly if the clan limit is 20 members. i think i remember ender saying that he doesnt plan on changing it but i sure hope he does.

I REALLY like this small clan size limit. It really limits the abilities of clans to stack. Granted right now it may not appear so because of Eternal, but look at Civilian. They're doing extremely well.

But i agree with cwgarza, better to ask about an idea and see the reaction of the people playing the game(not the answer the admin gives every time it is asked) and be discussed in an orderly manner.

jup .. people change their minds over time so if you don't ask again, no one will ever know :D

its very discouraging to other players looking to post their ideas, when someone mentions something and within a minute it gets shot down. lol

It's not the idea being squashed that usually is discouraging to me. It's the continues of "No" from everyone with no viable discusion as to why not. That is annoying, irritating, and very frustrating to me when people just say "no, I hate it" or "Ender already said no" but still gives no reason why he said no or leads you to the other thread where he said no.