suggestions

Here we go. Like my suggestion in the other thread about New Monthly Rewards, I'd like to make a suggestion so Ed can see it easier :)

Make it so that a clan WILL NOT receive clan trophies IF;

1 - The Clan doesn't have a an over all Energy Ratio of at least 1.15

OR

2 - 15 of the 20 Members must have an Energy Ratio over 1.15

Some dumping clans will still get trophies, but most will not. Dumping is fine just like whores were in Bots2. Just try not to reward them as much :)

Thanks!
-Alan

No. Dumb idea.

There is no reason for this. It would hurt non-dumper clans as well. And as for "try not to reward them," to be honest, a clan trophy means almost nothing to a dumper. This wouldn't affect dumping at all, but would hurt actual clans with casuals and newbies.

thinking about this now neps is right it would affect non-dumper clans too, not that but people just get rid of their clans when they cba win dumping the bots no more and make a fresh set

I think this just makes the clan rankings/trophies systems more complex instead of addressing the root cause of dumper clans being ranked highly, which should be addressed on its own. And as others mentioned, it would probably hurt "real" clans more than dumper clans anyway.

I have some ideas in this direction that I'll probably put out for discussion at some point, but nothing concrete for now.